Ohio Valley
  • Current Conditions
    82°
    Partly Cloudy
  • 5:00pm
    80°
  • 8:00pm
    75°
Full Forecast » Radar ImageCurrent Radar »
E-Mail News Alerts
Get breaking news and daily headlines.
Browse all e-mail newsletters
Related To Story

Sheriff Defends Armed Escort At Amish Community

POSTED: 2:31 pm EDT September 19, 2007
UPDATED: 11:36 am EDT September 21, 2007

The Jefferson County sheriff said he and his deputies received several death threats from an Amish bishop with regard to a child custody dispute, prompting him to have the regional SWAT team on standby Tuesday.

Sheriff Fred Abdalla was ordered to take Wilma Troyer's daughters, ages 21 months and 9 months, as part of a domestic dispute with her husband who currently lives with his family in Potter County, Pa.

The sheriff said he and one other deputy went alone up to the school to serve the court order, but said Troyer, an Amish teacher, instead locked herself in the building.

Attorney Bryan Felmet, spokesman for the Amish community, called the incident a raid and said the one-room schoolhouse was the stage for a dramatic showdown between an Amish mother and sheriff's deputies.

Felmet said there were 29 children in the school on county Road 53 when several cruisers from the sheriff's department and a SWAT team entered the grounds.

"Machine guns, and bulletproof vests, and camouflage -- what is that about? There's no explanation," said Felmet. "I don't care. There's no explanation unless he thought those children were armed and dangerous."

In a rare move, the Amish -- who typically do not go on camera -- described the incident on a video posted on YouTube.com.

"(The sheriff) was knocking on the door, 'Open up, open. I want to talk to Wilma Troyer. Open that door. I have a court order,'" Troyer said. "Those children were in there crying and screaming, 'They're going to shoot us.'"'

Troyer said the children exited the schoolhouse, surrounding her, and walked down the road. She was detained and served with the court papers at a nearby farmhouse and her children removed into the custody of their father.

Samuel Mullet, an Amish bishop and Wilma Troyer's father, said the community is outraged.

"I said, 'This is crazy. You know none of us guys have guns out here. We wouldn't use them if we had them,'" Mullet said.

But Abdalla disagreed and said Mullet threatened his life on more than one occasion.

"If it wasn't for all the allegations being made, for all the statements being made and the threats being made, we would have handled it differently," the sheriff said.

Abdalla said he doesn't regret the show of force.

"I don't care if it's a school or church. I'm going to take whatever action is necessary," he said. "Based on threats to my life and on my deputies' lives, based on the threats (Mullet) has made on his own family, surely Mr. Bryan Felmet doesn't think I should approach that situation with sticks in my hand."

Felmet maintains his stance that the situation was not handled correctly.

"To comment on Fred's comment: 'What am I supposed to do, go out there with sticks?' No, Fred, you're supposed to call me," said Felmet. "And my client will come bring the children pursuant to a court order."

Abdalla said the children were never in any danger.

"When they came out of the school, I kept telling the children, 'Kids, nothing is wrong here. Nobody is going to get hurt. You don't need to cry,'" he said.

Abdalla also said there are "some very serious allegations" of molestation and attempted rape in that Amish community. The sheriff's department is also investigating the death of a 2-year-old Amish boy who lived in the community. An autopsy on that toddler was never performed though required by law, Abdalla said.

He showed a stack of letters from people he claims left the Bergholz community and are begging him to step in. Further, he said the Amish in that community are being threatened psychologically.

"(Mullet) told the children we were going to get them and put needles in them. My God, any child would be scared," Abdalla said.

A hearing is scheduled in Jefferson County magistrate court on Thursday to discuss custody of Troyer's children. Stay with NEWS9 and WTOV9.com for continuing coverage as details become available.

-Renee Cardelli & John Paul, NEWS9


Market Place

Sponsor Links

Links We Like

Sponsored Content
Not everyone has an unlimited budget and tons of space. Learn how to make the most out of your kitchen remodeling project. More Details

Learn about 7 of the most common skin rashes and everything you need to know to avoid getting them and treating them if you already do. More Details

Make sure you are prepared to get the very best offer you can with some great negotiating tips. More Details

You can save big money on the purchase of your next vehicle just by searching smarter. This helpful tool can find you the very best deals in your area today. More Details

Like online video? Then you'll love Now See This.

Links We Like includes a selection of information, tools and resources from our partners and sponsors.

Credit Center

560? 675? 720? The Average US Credit Score is 692. What is Your Score? See it Instantly Online for $0. More
Experian

Back To Top