WTOV9.com News 

Story

Columbiana County Man Pleads Guilty To Killing Wife

A Columbiana County man pleaded guilty Thursday to two counts in connection with killing his wife.

J.C. Amato pleaded guilty to a lesser charge of voluntary manslaughter with a firearms specification. Investigators said he killed his wife, Tonia Amato, on July 1, 2007, inside their Wellsville home. He was originally charged with murder in February 2008.

Amato also pleaded guilty to one count of a possession of a dangerous ordinance. Officials said that charge had to do with Amato having bomb-making materials and firearms at his parents' house.

As part of the plea agreement, the defense and prosecution are recommending Amato serve a total of eight years in prison. One stipulation of the plea deal was that Amato begin serving time immediately.

Court documents previously disclosed that J.C. Amato told police he did shoot his wife at their home, but he said it was in self-defense.

A Wellsville police officer said J.C. Amato told him "his wife tried to shoot him with a .22-caliber handgun that belonged to him." J.C. Amato then stated he returned fire and shot her between the eyes with a separate handgun.

Amato was initially scheduled to head to trial on Aug. 18, 2009, but his defense attorneys filed several motions and Special Prosecutor Lynn Grimshaw requested a continuance.

A judge ordered a pre-sentencing investigation and a deposition is scheduled for March 5.

While Amato was for the most part emotionless as he faced the just, the victim's family was in tears but said they were relieved the case is nearly over.

"It's time for it to be over. It's been a very long 30 months. It's been delay after delay and one issue after another," said Kathy Brundage, Tonia Amato's mother.

The prosecutor in Columbiana County recused himself from the case because of his relationship to J.C. Amato's father.

Stay with NEWS9 and WTOV9.com for continuing coverage as details become available.

More Headlines

Daily Survey

Sponsored By:
The Bachmann Hess Legal Team
Are you confident the health care bill will pass the House this week?

Message Board

Share your thoughts about what's going on in the news today and read what others from across the Valley are thinking. Full Story ››


Message Board

Share your thoughts about what's going on in the news today and read what others from across the Valley are thinking. Full Story ››